| Editor: | Associate Editors: | |
| GARETH SCHMELING Department of Classics University of Florida Gainesville, Florida 32611-7435 Tel. (352) 392-2075 FAX (352) 846-0297 email: schmelin@classics.ufl.edu |
Vol. 29, Nos. 1 & 2 , May 1999 |
Raymond Astbury Barry Baldwin Ewen Bowie Gian Biagio Conte Niklas Holzberg B.P. Reardon Gerald Sandy |
| Editor for On-line Edition: Jean Alvares, Department of Classics and General Humanities, Montclair State University. Telephone (973) 655-5292. alvaresj@mail.montclair.edu | ||
(Publication of the Newsletter is made possible by the generous support of Martha B. McDonald who dedicates this volume in memoriam to her beloved parents, Sgt. Carl E. and Toyo M. Byrd)
![]()
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Bagordo, A., "Manum de tabula (Petron.
76,9)," Glotta 134-136 (1995-96). B. re-punctuates from manum de tabula:
sustuli to tabula, sustuli and translates "... habe ich die Hand von der
Tafel und mich aus den Handelsgeschäft genommen..."
Balot, R., "Foucault, Chariton, and the
Masculine Self," Helios 25 (1998) 139-162.
Beck, R., review of R. Merkelbach, Isis regina --
Zeus Sarapis. Die griechisch-ägyptische Religion nach den Quellen dargestellt
(Stuttgart/Leipzig: Teubner, 1995) in Klio 80 (1998) 525-527.
Billault, A., "Romanciers grecs et
tragédies," Actes du Colloque, Le Théâtre grec antique: La Tragédie .
Cahiers de la Villa "Kerylos," No 8, Beaulieu-sur-Mer
(Alpes-Maritimes). (Paris 1998) 179-194.
Billault, A., "Le comique d'Achilles Tatius et
les réalités de l'époque impériale," in Le Rire des Anciens , eds., M.
Trede, P. Hoffmann (Paris: Presses de l'Ecole Normale Supérieure, 1998) 143-158.
Biville, F., "Et tu cum esses capa , cocococo
(Petr. 59.2). Metaphores et onomatopées animalières dans Sat . 57-59," Latomus
55 (1996) 855-862.
Biville, F., "'Sophos !' universi
clamamus (Pétrone 40,1). Acclamations grecques et latins dans les loisirs des
Romains," in Les Loisirs et l'héritage de la culture classique , ed. J.-M.
André (Bruxelles: Latomus , 1996) 310-318.
Bloomer, W. Martin, Latinity and Literary Society
at Rome (Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 1997) 327 pp. Chapter 6,
"The Rival in the Text," pp. 196-241, is an essay on the Satyrica .
Bonfanti, M., "Due note a Petronio," AVM
56 (1988) 57-72.
Brioso, M., "Aspectos formales del relato en la
novela griega antigua," in Actitudes Literarias en la Grecia Romana , eds. M.
Brioso, F.J. González Ponce (Sevilla: Libros Pórtico, 1998) 123-207.
Brioso, M., "Modelos narrativos de la novela
griega antigua," in Homenaje a Esperanza Albarrán Gómez (Sevilla: Instituto
San Isidoro, 1998) 39-53.
Brioso, M., "Aspectos del estilo directo en la
novela griega antigua," Habis 30 (1999) 153-173.
Callebat, Louis, Langages du roman latin .
Spudasmata Bd. 71 (Hildesheim: Olms, 1998) 301 pp., DM 98. "The mostly linguistic
studies brought together here have the goal of registering the originality of the genre
and the form of the Satyrica by Petronius and the Metamorphoses by Apuleius
by asking the question as to today's classification of these texts as 'novels'." From
the advertizing blurb.
Castelli, Anna, "A Proposito di Petronio 62, 5 mihi
anima in naso esse , e 62, 10 paene animam ebullivi ," GIF 49
(1997) 229-236.
Chiarini, G., "Il viaggo nella letteratura
greco-latina: da Ulisse ad Apollonio Re di Tiro (con una nuova proposita di lettura del
viaggio di Enea)," in Pothos: il Viaggio , la nostalgi (Trento:
Università degli Studi di Trento, 1995) 61-76.
Coccia, M., "Per una rilettura della Satire V di
Giovenale," in Storia letteratura e arte a Roma nel secondo secolo dopo Cristo
. Atti del Convegno: Mantova 8-9-10 ottobre 1992 (Firenze: Olschki, 1995) 3-25. cenae
of Virro, Nasidienus and Trimalchio.
Connors, C., Petronius the Poet. Verse and
Literary Tradition in the Satyricon (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1998). A
book-length study of the thirty-two poems in Petronius' Roman novel and the ways in which
they help to form the new genre.
Courtney, E., "Two Notes on Petronius," MD
40 (1998) 205-207. On 136.4 and 141.
Cueva, E., "The Analogue of the Hero of
Heliodorus' Aethiopica ," Syllecta Classica 9 (1998) 103-113.
Cueva, E., "The Art and Myth of Cupid and
Psyche ," in Veritatis Amicitiaeque Causa , eds., S. Byrne, E. Cueva
(Wauconda: Bolchazy-Carducci, 1999) 53-69.
Dell'Era, A., "Petronio, Sat .
62.9," BollClass 16 (1995) 118.
Döpp, S., "Roman/romanhafte Literatur," in
Lexikon der antiken Christlichen Literatur , ed. Siegmar Döpp und Wilhelm
Geerlings (Freiburg im Breisgau: Herder, 1998) 533-535. magnum in parvo , a concise
overview of the very real connection between the ancient novel and early Christian writers
.
Edsall, Margaret, The Role and Characterization of the Priest in the
Ancient Novel (Columbia University, Dissertation, New York, 1996). Dissertation Abstracts
1996-1997, 57 (5) 2023A.
Fernández-Savater
Martín, María Victoria, "Técnica narrativa en la Historia Apollonii Regis Tyri :
Las retrospecciones," Epos (Madrid) 13 (1997) 31-53. (M. Brioso)
Fick, N., "Divination
etrusque, divination italique dans le Satyricon ," in Les Écrivains et l' etrusca
disciplina de Claude à Trajan (Tours; Institut d'Études Latines de la Faculté des
Lettres et Sciences Humaines, 1995) 153-158.
Finkelpearl, E., Metamorphosis
of Language in Apuleius. A Study of Allusion in the Novel (Ann Arbor: University of
Michigan Press, 1998).
Francis, J.,
"Truthful Fiction: New Questions to Old Answers on Philostratus' Life of Apollonius
," AJP 119 (1998) 419-441.
Gagliardi, D., "Petronio e
Orazio (Elementi di affinità tra due esperienze letterarie diverse)," AAP 43 (1994)
329-338.
Galli, Lucia, "Petronio e
il romanze greco di Richard Heinze," Kleos 2 (1997) 77-98. Galli
provides an Italian translation of Heinze, "Petron und der griechische Roman," Hermes
34 (1899) 494-519, to mark the article's centenary.
Gamba, G.G., Petronio Arbitro
e i Cristiani. Ipotesi per una lettura contestuale del Satyricon (Roma: LAS-Libreria
Ateneo Salesiano, 1998). Biblioteca di Scienze Religiose 141. 411 pp. (Thanks to Michele
Coccia)
Genoni, L., "Petronio, Sat
. 116: un Prologo da commedia?," BSL 27 (1997) 454-459.
Gerschner, R., "Encolpius
Etymologus. Die etymologische Verwendung griechischer Wörter als Stilmerkmal von Petrons
urbaner Prosa," WS 110 (1997) 145-150. "Demnach könnte es sich um mehr
als ein allgemeines Stilmerkmal Petrons handeln: nämlich um die Abbildung eines Merkmales
des realen Sprachgebrauchs seiner gebildeten Zeitgenossen" (p. 150).
Giardina, G.
"Petroniana," Museum Criticum 30-31 (1995-96) 267-272.
Goga, S., "Encolpe dans la Cena
. Une aventure de l'ego ," Latomus 57 (1998) 375-379.
Gonoji, M., "Encolpius, the
Unreliable Narrator of the Satyricon ," JCS 46 (1998) 88-97 (in
Japanese).
Grewing, F., "Etymologie
und etymologische Wortspiele in den Epigrammen Martials," in Toto Notus in Orbe: Perspectiven
der Martial-Interpretation , ed. Farouk Grewing. Palingenesia Bd. 65 (Stuttgart:
Steiner, (1998) 315-356.
Grewing, F., review of E. Lefèvre, Studien zur
Struktur der "Milesischen" Novelle bei Petron und Apuleius (Stuttgart:
Steiner, 1997) in Anzeiger für die Altertumswissenschaft 51 (1998) 47-51.
"Eckard Lefèvres auch äußerlich ansprechend gestaltete Abhandlung, deren Ende ein
umfangreiches Literaturverzeichnis auf neuem Stand (88-93) sowie ein nach Namen und Sachen
gegliedertes Register (94-100) bilden, wird sich zügig einen festen Platz in der Roman-
und Novellistik-Philologie erobern" (50-51).
Guida, Augusto, "Un apographo sconosciuto di
Caritone, un' ambigua nota del Pasquali e una fallita impresa editoriale del '700,"
in Vetustatis Indagator : Scritti offerti a Filippo Di Benedetto, eds., V. Fera and
A. Guida (Messina 1999) 277-308.
Guillaume-Coirier, G., "Une farce de banquet: la
couronne d'or 'alabastrée' (Pétrone, Sat . LX, 1-4)," Latomus 57
(1998) 380-392.
Hadas, M., trans., Heliodorus. An Ethiopian
Romance (Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 1999). Reprint of the 1957
edition.
Harrison, S., "The Milesian Tales and the Roman
Novel," GCN 9 (1998) 61-73.
Harrison, S.J. "Dividing the Dinner: Book
Divisions in Petronius' Cena Trimalchionis ," CQ 48 (1998) 580-585. H.
would divide the Cena into 3 books: Book A (original Book 15?) 26.7-46.8; Book B
(Book 16?) 47.1-65.2; Book C (Book 17?) 65.3-78.8.
Harrison, S.J., Oxford Readings in the Roman Novel
(Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1999). S.J. Harrison, "Introduction:
Twentieth-Century Scholarship on the Roman Novel," xi-xxxix; F. Zeitlin,
"Petronius as Paradox: Anarchy and Artistic Integrity," 1-49 [TAPA 102
(1971) 631-684]; R. Beck, "Some Observations on the Narrative Technique of
Petronius," 50-73 [Phoenix 27 (1973) 42-61]; R. Astbury, "Petronius, P.
Oxy . 3010 and Menippean Satire," 74-84 [CP 72 (1977) 22-31]; G. Rosati,
"Trimalchio on Stage," 85-104 [Maia 35 (1985) 213-227]; H. Petersmann,
"Environment, Linguistic Situation and Levels of Style in Petronius' Satyrica
," 105-123 [ANRW II. 32.3 (1985) 1687-1705]; A. Barchiesi, "Traces of
Greek Narrative and the Roman Novel: a Survey," 124-141 [MCSN 4 (Rome 1986)
219-236]; A. Wlosok, "On the Unity of Apuleius' Metamorphoses ," 142-156
[Philologus 113 (1969) 68-84]; J. Tatum, "The Tale in Apuleius' Metamorphoses
," 157-194 [TAPA 100 (1969) 487-527]; W. Smith, "The Narrative Voice in
Apuleius' Metamorphoses ," 195-216 [TAPA 103 (1972) 513-534]; H.J.
Mason, "Fabula graecanica : Apuleius and his Greek Sources," 217-236 [B.
Hijmans, T. van der Paardt, eds., Aspects of Apuleius' Golden Ass (Groningen 1978)
1-15]; R. T. van der Paardt, "The Unmasked 'I': Apuleius, Met
. 11.27," 237-246 [Mnemosyne 34 (1981) 96-106]; F. Millar, "The World of
the Golden Ass ," 247-268 [JRS 71 (1981) 63-75]; J. DeFilippo, "Curiositas
and the Platonism of Apuleius' Golden Ass ," 269-289 [AJP 111 (1990)
471-492]; E. Finkelpearl, "Psyche, Aeneas, and an Ass: Apuleius, Metamorphoses
6.10-6.21," 290-306 [TAPA 120 (1990) 333-348]. Bibliography 309-337.
Hock, Ronald F., Chance, J. Bradley, Perkins, Judith,
eds., Ancient Fiction and Early Christian Narrative . Society of Biblical
Literature, Symposium Series Number 6 (Atlanta: Scholars Press, 1998) ix + 317 pp. $49.95.
D. Konstan, "The Invention of Fiction," 3-17; G. Schmeling, "The Spectrum
of Narrative: Authority of the Author," 19-29; D. Edwards, "Pleasurable Reading
or Symbols of Power? Religious Themes and Social Context in Chariton," 31-46; K.
Chew, "Focalization in Xenophon of Ephesos' Ephesiaka ," 47-59; C. Shea,
"Setting the Stage for Romances: Xenophon of Ephesus and the Ecphrasis," 61-76;
R. Pervo, "A Nihilist Fabula: Introducing The Life of Aesop ," 77-120; R.
Hock, "Why New Testament Scholars Should Read Ancient Novels," 121-138; D.
MacDonald, "Secrecy and Recognitions in the Odyssey and Mark: Where Wrede Went
Wrong," 139-153; W. Shiner, "Creating Plot in Episodic Narratives: The Life
of Aesop and the Gospel of Mark," 155-176; C. Hedrick, "Conceiving the
Narrative: Colors in Achilles Tatius and the Gospel of Mark," 177-199; Brant, J.,
"Divine Birth and Apparent Parents: the Plot of the Fourth Gospel," 199-217; J.
Chance, "Divine Prognostications and the Movement of Story: an Intertextual
Exploration of Xenophon's Ephesian Tale and the Acts of the Apostles,"
219-234; L. Alexander, "'Better to Marry than to Burn': St. Paul and the Greek
Novel," 235-256; M. Aubin, "Reversing Romance? The Acts of Thecla and the
Ancient Novel," 257-272; C. Thomas, "Stories Without Texts and Without Authors:
the Problems of Fluidity in Ancient Novelistic Texts and Early Christian Literature,"
273-291; Bibliography 293-309; Index 311-317.
Hofmann, H., ed., Latin Fiction. The Latin Novel
in Context (London: Routledge, 1999) 288 pp. 45. Sixteen essays examine the subject:
"Petronius. The Satyrica ," G. Schmeling; "Petronius. The Cena
Trimalchionis ," J. Bodel; "Petronius. The Novellas," G. Anderson;
"Petronius. The Poems," C. Connors; "Apuleius. The Metamorphoses
," G. Sandy; "The Metamorphoses and its Greek Sources," H. Mason;
"The Inserted Tales," N. Shumate; "Amor and Psyche," G.Sandy; "The
History of Apollonius King of Tyre ," G. Schmeling; "Dares Phrygius and
Dictys Cretensis," S. Merkle; "The Latin Alexander: Curtius Rufus and the Late
Latin Texts," R. Stoneman; "Hagiographic Fiction as Entertainment," G.
Huber-Rebenich; "Medieval Interpretations of Amor and Psyche," C. Moreschini;
"Apollonius of Tyre in the Middle Ages," E. Archibald; "Alexander the Great
in the Middle Ages," R. Stoneman; "The Rediscovery of the Latin Novels between
the Middle Ages and the Eighteenth Century," R. Carver.
Holzberg, N., De roman in de oudheid
(Amsterdam: Polak & Van Gennep, 1998). Translation into Dutch of Der antike Roman
(Munich: Artemis Verlag, 1986). Up-dated bibliography.
Hunter, R., ed., Studies in Heliodorus .
Cambridge Philological Society, Supp. Vol. 21 (Cambridge: Cambridge Philological Society,
1998): E. Bowie, "Phoenician Games in Heliodorus' Aithiopika ," 1-18; P.
Hardie, "A Reading of Heliodorus, Aithiopika 3.4.1-5.2," 19-39; R.
Hunter, "The Aithiopika of Heliodorus: beyond Interpretation," 40-59;
J.R. Morgan, "Narrative Doublets in Heliodorus' Aithiopika ," 60-78; J.
Hilton, "An Ethiopian Paradox: Heliodorus, Aithiopika 4.8," 78-92; T.
Whitmarsh, "The Birth of a Prodigy: Heliodorus and the Genealogy of Hellenism,"
93-124; P. Agapitos, "Narrative, Rhetoric, and 'Drama' Rediscovered: Scholars and
Poets in Byzantium Interpret Heliodorus," 125-156; C. Bertoni and M. Fusillo,
"Heliodorus Parthenopaeus: the Aithiopika in Baroque Naples," 157-181;
D.Selden, "Aithiopika and Ethiopianism," 182-217; Bibliography, 219-232.
Ilushechkin, V., "Legal and Illegal Marriage in
Apuleius," in Power, Men, Society in the Ancient World . Papers of the
Conference of the Ancient Association (Moscow 1997) 392-396.
Ilushechkin, V., "The Peculiarities of
Controversy between Paganism and Christianity in the 2nd Century A.D. (Apuleius's Story
about the Lewd Wife of a Miller -- Met . IX.14)," Journal of Historical,
Philological and Cultural Studies 5 (1998) 111-116 (Moscow-Magnitogorsk). In Russian.
Jedrkiewicz, S., Il convitato sullo sgabello:
Plutarco, Esopo ed in Sette Savi (Pisa 1997).
Jouanno, Corinne, "Un èpisode embarrassant de
l'histoire d'Alexandre: la prise de Thèbes," Ktema 18 (1993) 245-258.
Jouanno, Corinne, "Alexandre et Olympia: de
l'histoire au mythe," BAGB (1995) 211-230.
Jouanno, Corinne, "Recits d'enfances dans la
litterature byzantine d'imagination," Pris-Ma 12 (1996) 39-56.
Jouanno, Corinne, "L'homme aux trois pères ou
les ambiguités du Roman d'Alexandre," in Généalogies Mythiques , eds. D.
Auger, S. Said (Paris: Université de Paris, 1998) 447-463.
Jouanno, Corinne, trans., Digénis Akritas, le
heros des frontières. Une épopée byzantine. Version de Grottaferrata .
Introduction, pp. 7-186, par Corinne Jouanno (Turnhout: Brepols, 1998). Maps 187-188;
Translation 193-309; Bibliography 311-319.
Kleijwegt, M., "The Social Dimensions of the
Gladiatorial Combat in Petronius' Cena Trimalchionis ," GCN 9 (1998)
75-96.
Knobloch, I., "Matavitatau . Der
Schlachtruf antiker Legionäre," RhM 139 (1996) 368-369.
Kortekaas, G., "Historia Apollonii Regis Tyri:
eine Kurznotiz," ZPE 122 (1998) 60. Is the poem at c.11 (storm at sea)
inspired by Virgil A . 1.81-141 or Achilles Tatius 3.1-3.5? [read
for
]. Note on Notus clipeo /picea or Notus
clypeum .
Laes, C., "Forging Petronius: François Nodot
and Fake Petronian Fragments," Humanistica Lovaniensia 47 (1998) 358-402.
Lateiner, D., "Blushes and Pallor in Ancient
Fictions," Helios 25 (1998) 163-189.
Los, A., "La Condition sociale des affranchis
privés au 1er siècle après J.C.," Annales (ESC)
50 (1995) 1011-1043.
Marblestone, H., "Matavitatau in Petronius, Satyricon
62.9: crux interpretum ," in Boundaries of the Ancient Near Eastern World:
a Tribute to Cyrus H. Gordon , eds., M. Lubetski et al . (Sheffield: Sheffield
Academic Press, 1998) 493-510.
Mariotti, M., "Sul contrasto di modelli nella
retorica dell' aegritudo : consolatio per exempla e fletus immodicus in
AL 692 R e Petron. 115, 6-20," MD 38 (1997) 87-123.
Martin, René, Le Satyricon. Pétrone . Textes
fondateurs (Paris: Ellipses, 1999) 174 pp.
McGinn, Thomas, Prostitution, Sexuality, and the
Law in Ancient Rome (New York: Oxford University Press, 1998) xvi + 416 pp.
McGlathery, D., "Petronius' Tale of the Widow of
Ephesus and Bakhtin's Material Bodily Lower Stratum," Arethusa 31 (1998)
313-336.
Mey, Dario, Curiosità: Petronio Arbitro, La
Matrona di Efeso . Testo latino a fronte, traduzione e commento di Dario Mey. [Also
Latin and Italian, il Fanciullo di Pergamo]. In Appendice, La Vedova nella poesia popolare
e negli aforismi (Valentano: Scipioni, 1996). Thanks to Michele Coccia and Aldo Setaioli.
Müller, K. review of I.C. Giardina, Rita Cuccioli
Melloni, eds., Petronii Arbitri Satyricon (Torino: Paravia, 1995) in Gnomon
70 (1998) 494-497.
Öberg, J., ed., Petronius. Cena Trimalchionis
. Acta Universitatis Stockholmiensis, Studia Latina Stockholmiensia XLII (Stockholm:
Almquist & Wiksell, 1999) xx + 58 pp. Abstract: "The Petronian Satyrica
and especially its Trimalchio episode abound with interpretative and textual difficulties,
the transmitted text being almost as faulty as it is funny. From the editio princeps
of 1664 up to the authoritative Teubner edition by Konrad Müller 1995, numerous brilliant
scholars have scrutinized the text of Petronius, presenting ingenious solutions to its
many problems. The aim of the present new edition is to question a number of traditionally
accepted readings, which implies either returning to the manuscript version or to an early
solution of a specific problem, or may even mean proposing quite new conjectures. The
Latin text, preceded by introductory notes on the manuscript sources and on the present
edition, is accompanied by a combined critical and explanatory apparatus . Indices
of proper names and remarkable words conclude the booklet."
Papademetriou, J. -Th., Aesop as an Archetypal
Hero (Athens 1997).
Perotti, P., "Ius cenae (Pétrone
35,7)," LEC 65 (1997) 345-349.
Plazenet, L., "L' ébahissement et la
delectation . Reception comparée et poetiques du roman grec en France et en
Angleterre aux XVIe et XVIIe siècles
(Paris: Honoré Champion, 1997) 899pp.
Ramelli, Ilaria, "Petronio e i Cristiani:
Allusioni al Vangelo di Marco nel Satyricon ," Aevum 70 (1996) 75-80.
This article caught the eye of the popular press in Italy and was discussed in the
mass-media: M. Cecchetti, "Petronio contro Marco," Avvenire (29 May 1996)
19; C. Medial, "Petronio, una parodia del Vangelo di Marco," Corriere della
Sera (5 June 1996) 29; S. Paci, "Petronio, c' è un Vangelo tra le righe," 30
Giorni (16 June 1996) 48-50; R. Fiol, "Marco e Petronio. Quando Nerone leggeva il
Vangelo," Litterae Communionis Tracce 23/10 (November 1996) 62-63. In Gamba, Petronio
Arbitro e i Cristiani .
Reardon, B.P., "Apographs and Atticists:
Adventures of a Text," Celebratio: Thirtieth Anniversary Essays at Trent
University , eds., J. Bews et al . (Peterborough: Trent University, 1998)
67-75. A history of the text of Chariton's Callirhoe .
Ruiz-Montero, C., "La novela de Nino y
los comienzos del género," in Las Letars griegas bajo el imperio , eds. M.
Brioso, F.J. González Ponce (Sevilla: Libros Pórtico, 1996) 135-150.
Ruiz-Montero, C., "La Concepción de la mujer en
los textos griegos de comienzo del imperio," in Mujer e Investigación , eds.,
Lola Frutas Balibrea, Remedios Maurandi Guirado (Murcia: University of Murcia, 1998)
Chapter 8.
Salanitro, M., "L'uccello pio. Petronio, 55, 6
v.4," RFIC 124 (1996) 300-305. For the words ciconia ... / pietaticultrix
S. stresses the importance of, and connection to, ciconia and pietas .
Setaioli, A., "Il novae simplicitatis opus
(Sat . 132.15.2) e la poetica petroniana," Prometheus 23 (1997)
145-164.
Setaioli, A., "Cinque poesie petroniane (Sat
. 82.5, 83.10, 108.14, 126.18, 132.15)," Prometheus 24 (1998) 217-242.
Sham, M., Characterization in Petronius' Satyricon
(Dissertation, State University of New York at Buffalo, NY, 1994). Summary in Dissertation
Abstracts 1994-1995 55 (11) 3500A-3501A.
Siewert, W., Petronius. Satyricon Libri .
Auswahl mit vollständigen Text der Cena Trimalchionis . Eingeleitet, kommentiert
und mit Zusatztexten versehen von Walter Siewert. Vol. 1 Text, Vol. 2 Kommentar (Münster:
Verlag Aschendorff, 1994). Very good and useful school edition of the Satyrica .
Thanks to Farouk Grewing, Koln.
Sommariva, G., "Il Barbiere di Mida (Petr. Satyr
. fr. 28 Ernout)," Filologia Antica e Moderna 1 (1991) 107-117. Allusion to
Ovid M . 11.172ff.; Frag . belongs in Satyrica 116-117.
Soverini, P., Note a Petronio, Sat . 132,
15," BSL 27 (1997) 460-469. On quid me constricta ... Are these the
sentiments of the author?
Stramaglia, A. Res inauditae, incredulae: Storie
di fantasmi nel mondo greco-latino (Bari: Levante Editore, 1999). "Le Rane,"
Collana di Studi e Testi: Studi 24. 552 pp. After a most informative introduction which
lays out the material to be covered, S. divides his book into 5 chapters: 1) "Case
infestate" 2) "Terrori balneari" 3) "La morte amoureuse" 4)
"Sepolcri senza requie" 5) "Fantasmi di guerra." Each chapter has an
excellent introduction to the subject, everything nicely documented, the Greek or Latin
texts with Italian translation, detailed notes to the texts, and a few fitting
photographs. S. has packed a wealth of information into this handsome book. The ancient
Greek and Latin novels play a major role in S.'s book, and scholars of the novel will want
to go through this work thoroughly.
Swain, S., ed., Oxford Readings in the Greek Novel
(Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1999). S. Swain, "A Century and More of the Greek
Novel," 3-35; E. Bowie, "The Greek Novel," 39-59 [P. Easterling, B. Knox,
eds., The Cambridge History of Classical Literature , I, Greek Literature
(Cambridge 1985) 683-699]; M. Fusillo, "The Conflict of Emotions: a Topos in
the Greek Erotic Novel," 60-82 [MH 47 (1990) 201-221]; S. Said, "Rural
Society in the Greek Novel, or the Country Seen from the Town," 83-107 [E. Frézouls,
ed., Sociétés urbaines, sociétés rurales dans l'Asie Mineure et la Syrie
hellénistiques et romaines (Strasbourg 1987) 149-171]; B. Egger, "The Role of
Women in the Greek Novel: Woman as Heroine and Reader," 108-136 [CGN 1 (1988)
33-66]; T. Hägg, "Callirhoe and Parthenope : the Beginnings of the
Historical Novel," 137-160 [Classical Antiquity 6 (1987) 184-204]; B.P.
Reardon, "Theme, Structure and Narrative in Chariton," 163-188 [YCS 27
(1982) 1-27]; B. Effe, "Longus: Towards a History of Bucolic and its Function in the
Roman Empire," 189-209 [Hermes 110 (1982) 65-84]; L. Cresci, "The Novel
of Longus the Sophist and the Pastoral Tradition," 210-242 [A&R 26 (1981)
1-25]; B.P. Reardon, "Achilles Tatius and Ego-Narrative," 243-258 [J.R. Morgan,
ed., Greek Fiction: the Greek Novel in Context (London 1994) 80-96]; J.R. Morgan,
"The Story of Knemon in Heliodorus' Aithiopika ," 259-285 [JHS 109
(1989) 99-113]; J. Winkler, "The Mendacity of Kalasiris and the Narrative Strategy of
Heliodorus' Aithiopika ," 286-350 [YCS 27 (1982) 93-158]; M. Fusillo,
"The Mirror of the Moon: Lucian's A True Story -- from Satire to Utopia,"
351-381 [Poétique 19/73 (1988) 109-135]; Bibliography 382-412.
Tandoi, V., "Come entrare a Crotone (Petr. Satyr
. 117)," in Scritti di Filologia e di Storia della cultura classica , vol. 2
(Pisa 1992) 624-632.
Várhelyi, Zsuzsanna, "Representations of the
'Other': the Religion of the Egyptians in the Greek Novel," in Heorte: Studia in
Honorem Johannis Sarkady Septuagenarii , eds., Zoltán Nemes, György Németh
(Debrecen: KLTE, 1997) 89-113 [Történeti Tanulmányok VI: Hungarian Polis Studies 2].
Thanks to William Hansen.
Vielberg, M., "Der Dichter und Erzähler Eumolp
-- ein unzeitgemäßer Held Petron?" in Der unzeitgemäße Held in der
Weltliteratur , ed., G. Kaiser. Jenaer Germanistische Forschungen, Bd. 1 (Heidelberg:
C. Winter, 1998) 29-45. Thanks to Farouk Grewing, Köln.
Wolff,É., trans., Histoire du roi Apollonius de
Tyr , présenté, traduit du latin et annoté (Paris: Anatolia, 1996).
Wolff, É., Le roman grec et latin . Thèmes
& études (Paris: Ellipses, 1997) 120 pp. "Ce livre étudie l'origine du genre
romanesque dans l'Antiquité, analyse chacun des romans antiques, dégage leurs constantes
et leurs différences -- le roman grec est un roman d'amour, ce n'est pas vrai du roman
latin --, et montre aussi l'influence déterminante qu'ils ont exercée sur les
littératures de l'Europe moderne, au XVe siécle
notamment" (from the back cover).
Zimmerman, M. et al ., eds., Aspects of
Apuleius' Golden Ass : vol. 2, Cupid and Psyche (Groningen: Egbert Forsten,
1998) XII + 236 pp. K. Dowden, "Cupid and Psyche: a Question of the Vision of
Apuleius," 1-22; Maeve C. O'Brien, "'For every tatter in its mortal dress':
Love, the Soul and her Sisters," 23-34; P. James, "The Unbearable Lightness of
Being: Levis Amor in the Metamorphoses of Apuleius," 35-49; S.J.
Harrison, "Some Epic Structures in Cupid and Psyche ," 51-68; W. Smith,
"Cupid and Psyche Tale: Mirror of the Novel," 69-82; Danielle van Mal-Maeder,
Maaike Zimmerman, "The Many Voices in Cupid and Psyche ," 83-102; H.
Pinkster, "The Use of Narrative Tenses in "Apuleius' Amor and Psyche
," 103-111; S. Brodersen, "Cupid's Palace -- a Roman Villa (Apul. Met .
5,1)," 113-125; S. Mattiacci, "Neoteric and Elegiac Echoes in the Tale of Cupid
and Psyche by Apuleius," 127-149; Stelios Panayotakis, "Slander and Warfare in
Apuleius' Tale of Cupid and Psyche," 151-164; Wytse H. Keulen, "A Bird's
Chatter: Form and Meaning in Apuleius' Metamorphoses 5, 28," 165-188; Jan L.
de Jong, "Il pittore a le volte è puro poeta: Cupid and Psyche in Italian
Renaissance Painting," 189-215 (13 plates); Bibliography 217-228; General Index
229-236. This volume is a worthy successor to Aspects of Apuleius' Golden Ass
(1978).
![]()
NACHLEBEN
Turner, Paul, The Life of Thomas Hardy
(Oxford: Blackwell, 1998). The readers of the PSN will be pleasantly surprised to
note Hardy's use of material from Longus' Daphnis and Chloe in various of his
novels. In a earlier age when the word literate always implied a knowledge of the classics
Hardy read fairly widely in Greek and Latin literature. Turner's biography should add much
fuel to the revival of interest in Hardy.
Maderna, B., Satyricon, opéra en un act d'après
Pétrone . CD: Éditions Salabert, Paris, 1998.
Thackwray, Robert, Effective Evaluation of
Training and Development in Higher Education (Sheffield, UK: Universities' and
Colleges' Staff Development Agency, 1997) 25, quotes the (in)famous lines from Petronius:
"We trained hard, but it seemed that every time we were beginning to form up in teams
we would be reorganized ..."
Evans, Patricia, "Can I quote you (whoever you
are)?," The Globe and Mail (1 May 1998) A24. On the (in)famous lines from
Petronius: "We trained hard..." These lines have taken on a life of their own
and a Web Site of their own! www.research.att.com/~ reads/petronius.html. Thanks to Barry
Baldwin, emeritus non defessus .
Maderna, Bruno, "Satyricon , un'opera
buffa in piena regola." This Satyricon was written in 1973 and the performance
in Venice, Italy in October 1998 was reviewed by Paolo Gallarati in La Stampa , 10
October 1998; by Michelangelo Zurletti in La Repubblica , 18 October 1998. Thanks
to Michele Coccia.
![]()
NOTICES
MADRID CONFERENCE
Primer Simposio Internacional de Filología Griega, Madrid, Universidad Nacional de Educación a Distancia, Departamento de Filología Clásica, 18-21 February 1998: El Amor en la Literatura Griega. M. Brioso, El amor, de la elegía helenística a la novela; E. Paglialunga, El amor en la novela griega.
UNIVERSITY OF KENTUCKY NOVEL CONFERENCE
James Francis announces a Colloquium on the Pre-Modern Novel, 23-24 March 1999, University of Kentucky, Lexington. The speakers on 23 March are: Simon Goldhill, The Erotic Eye: Cultural Conflict and Empire Society in the 2nd Century; Steve Nimis, In medias res: Beginning Again in the Middle in the Ancient Novel; William Hansen, Pseudo-Documentarism: Musings on Novels Found in Temples and Tombs. On 24 March: Simon Goldhill, Cultivating a Look: Self-Presentation and the Expertise of Observation; Jennifer Tunberg, Neo-Latin Novels as a Genre and Samuel Gotts Nova Solyma (London: 1648).
LECTURES AT THE PETRONIAN SOCIETY MUNICH SECTION
Niklas Holzberg, Praeses
11 May 1998: |
B.P. Reardon (Lion-sur-Mer), Heliodorus Aethiopica: La grande illusion? |
15 June 1998: |
Karl Galinsky (Austin), Das Augustische in der Augustischen Kultur. |
(lecture schedule shortened because N. Holzberg heeded the Siren voices of Italy and
taught at the Venice International University in Winter 1998-99).
BOSTON AREA ROMAN STUDIES CONFERENCE
Ann Vasaly announces a conference on 23 April 1999 at Boston University. The speakers are: Vasily Rudich, Paideia in Persius and Petronius; Nancy Shumate, The Satyricon and the Question of Authenticity; John Bodel, Liber esto: Free(d) Speech at the Banquet of Trimalchio (Pet. 41-46).
APULEIUS COLLOQUIUM
York University held a conference, Pinning the Tale: Apuleius Golden
Ass in its Cultural Context, on 24 April 1999. The speakers were Ewen Bowie,
Elaine Fantham, Ellen Finkelpearl, James River, Gerald Sandy. The conference is intended
to coincide with the Canadian Opera Companys new production of The Golden Ass,
an opera with libretto by Robertson Davis and music by Randolph Peters.
APA MEETING, 27-30 DECEMBER 1998
WASHINGTON, DC
S. McGill, The Literary Lives of a Scheintod: Clitophon and Leucippe 5.7 and Greek Epigram; L. Kim, The Trouble with Kalasiris: Authority, Duplicity & Self-Presentation in Heliodorus; J. Alvares, Eros and the Reformation of Love and Society in Longus Daphnis and Chloe; D. Larmour, Lucians True History: Allegories of Reading; S. Trzaskoma, Longus, Thucydides and their Mytilenian Debates; K. Olson, Slave Narrative in Apuleius Metamorphoses; E. Cueva, Art and Myth and Cupid and Psyche; G. Jensson, The Milesian Tale: Short Story on Novel?
TAUTON"S COLLEGE, SOUTHAMPTON
Hopwood, K., "Trimalchio's Life and Society." Lecture, 25 November 1998
PSN AND THE WEB
If anyone wishes to add items to Jean Alvares' bibliography for the ancient novel, first go to http://www.uky.edu/ArtsSciences/ Classics/novelform.html and check the bibliography. If the items are not listed there, then go to http://130.68.50.82:591/bibsearch.html and add to the bibliography. The password is Petron.
WORKS IN PROGRESS
Panayotakis, Costas is working on a
revised version of P. Dinnage's translation of the Satyricon with Introduction and
Notes. To be published by Wordsworth's Classics in summer/fall.
Keulen, Wytse, is preparing a commentary in English
on Apuleius Met . 1 as a doctoral dissertation at the University of Groningen.
![]()
William Hansen, ed, Anthology of Ancient Greek Popular Literature . Bloomington: Indiana, 1998. xxix + 349, $18.95 (paper) $39.95 (cloth)
Review by Richard I. Pervo
University of Minnesota
Hansen, Professor of Classical Studies and
Folklore at Indiana, has produced what one hopes for in an anthology, for this volume can
be used as a textbook yet is of benefit for the scholar, has clear, well-written, and
well-formed introductions that avoid eccentricity while noting different viewpoints, and
provides a representative selection of mostly complete works. These are: An Ephesian
Tale, The Acts of Paul and Thecla, Secundus the Silent Philosopher , the Onos, The
Aesop Romance, The Alexander Romance , selections from Phlegon's Marvels (on
which see Hansen's translation with commentary: Phlegon of Tralles' Book of Marvels
[Exeter: University of Exeter Press, 1996]), excerpts from the Collectio Augustana
of fables, about one-fifth of the jokes in the Philogelos , The Oracles of
Astrampsychus , and c. forty epitaphs. A number of the non-fiction items appear in
translation for the first time, whereas the novels come from extant versions, only one of
which (M. Hadas's rendition of Xenophon of Ephesus) will elicit scholarly frowns. (Hansen
uses Daly's Aesop . Readers of the PSN may be interested to know that a more
accurate translation based upon a superior text may be found in L. Wills, The Quest of
the Historical Gospel [London: Routledge, 1997], 181-215.)
This anthology contains two general types of
material: fictional and "practical." In the general introduction Hansen takes up
the issue of definition. Rejecting qualitative, quantitative (H. observes that S.
Stephens's counting of papyri implies, if valid, its opposite: the most popular ancient
writings were Homer and the Jewish and Christian scriptures), and sociological approaches,
he opts for aesthetic criteria. Chief among these is the primacy of content over form. In
sum: "The popular aesthetic, as expressed in literature, manifests itself typically
as easy to read, continually engaging and replete with action and sensation." (xvii).
Other characteristic features are unknown authorship, textual fluidity, and
"nonorganic" composition. This last is probably the most debatable, as scholars
keep discovering structure in many popular works long believed to lack it.
The benefits of this volume for the specialist
interested in non-sophistic novels are three-fold. One is the valuable discussion of that
elusive adjective "popular." Another is Hansen's apt deployment of comparative
material and methods. Finally, the juxtaposition of fictional and practical helps to
illuminate the cultural environment of those who read popular fiction. The questions posed
in The Oracles of Astrampsychus , for example, provide enough motifs for the
construction of a typical action-packed novel.
Louis Callebat, Languages du roman latin . Spudasmata Bd. 71 (Hildesheim: Georg Olms, 1998) 301 pp., DM 98.
The first part of this book (17-218) is a collection of nine
previously published articles: "Les Satyrica de Pétrone et l'Âne d'or
d'Apulée sont-ils des Romans?," Euphrosyne 20 (1992) 149-164 (17-33);
"Structures narratives et modes de représentation dans les Satyrica de
Pétrone," REL 52 (1974) 281-303 (35-55); "Langages des Satyrica
de Pétrone," Biblos 68 (1992 [not 1998]) 1-11 (57-67); "Fabula de
nobis narratur : Esthétique et éthique dans les Satyrica de Pétrone,"
in Studia Philologica Varia in Honorem O. García de la Fuente (Madrid: Universidad
Europea de Madrid, 1994) 179-185 (69-76); "Nihil impossible arbitror :
Diversité et cohérence de l'oeuvre d'Apulée," in Filologia et Forme Letterarie
, Studi Offerte à Francesco della Corte (Urbino: Acti Grafiche Editoriali, 1983)
Vol. 4, 105-122 [not 187] (77-93); "La prose des Métamorposes: Génèse et
spécificitè," in Aspects of Apuleius' Golden Ass , eds. B.L. Hijmans, R. van
der Paardt (Groningen: Bouma's Boekhuis, 1978) 167-187 (95-122); "Formes et modes
d'expression dans le Métamorphoses d'Apuleé," ANRW II 34.2 (1994)
1616-1664 (123-179); "L' archaisme dans les Metamorphoses d'Apulée," REL
42 (1964) 346-361 (181-194); "La prosa d'Apulée dans le De Magia ," WS
18 (1984) 143-167 (195-218) The second part of this book is a collection of seven critical
readings (one of the Satyrica , six of the Metamorphoses ) each with text,
translation and critical reading: "Neutralisation d'un recit: Satyrica
22" (223-232); "Lectures d'un prologue: Metamorphoses 1,1"
(233-244); "Langage narratif et langage scénique: Métamorphoses 4,3"
(245-253); "Ironie et fantastique: Métamorphoses 3,24" (255-260);
"Préciosité et maniérisme: Métamorphoses 5,22" (261-265);
"Langage du Baroque: Métamorphoses 2,4" (267-272); "La style
'sublime': Métamorphoses 11,1" (273-283); Index (287-301).
A welcome collection of essays gathered from diverse
sources, by a senior scholar of the Roman novel.
![]()
ACHILLES TATIUS AND HELIODORUS: SOME 1998 PARALLELS
by Martin M. Winkler
This note describes a recent literary parallel to Achilles Tatius' Leucippe and Clitophon and two factual parallels to Heliodorus' Ethiopian Story .
1.
Achilles Tatius' adventure and mystery novel is noteworthy for the brazenness with
which he sets up and describes the gruesome death of his heroine (3.15), in full view of
eyewitnesses and followed by the dismemberment of her body, at a point when little more
than a quarter of the whole story has been told -- only to bring her back to life
immediately afterwards. Achilles kills off Leucippe for a second time (5.7), again before
witnesses and with another resurrection following in due course; for good measure, she is
later reported murdered for a third time (7.3). But as any reader, ancient or modern, will
have suspected at this point in the story, this is a false report. Leucippe remains
unharmed throughout and, by story's end, can enjoy a well-deserved happy ending with
Clitophon, the novel's hero and narrator.
A comparable fate, if without a romantic happy
ending, awaits Sarah Blundy, the heroine of Iain Pears's historical mystery An Instance
of the Fingerpost (1998; the title is a quotation from Francis Bacon). The novel, set
at Oxford in the 1660s, is primarily indebted to Umberto Eco's The Name of the Rose
(1980; English translation, 1983) and, for its narrative structure, to Akira Kurosawa's
film Rashomon (1950). Pears gives us four narrators who relate the same events from
their different perspectives and reveal to the reader different and mutually exclusive
pieces of information. All four describe the heroine's execution by public hanging; the
report by the first narrator includes a detailed description of the corpse's dismemberment
for the sake of anatomical research. At this stage we are a little more than a quarter
into the narrative, which comprises almost 700 pages. It is only toward the end of the
last narrator's story, after we have ourselves witnessed, as it were, Sarah's hanging
three times in previous accounts, that we find out what, presumably, really happened. She
has survived her execution, and the dismemberment turns out to have been an elaborate
piece of deception. In good narrative fashion as instanced by Achilles Tatius' and other
ancient novels, some of this borders on the incredible or far-fetched. Pears even outdoes
Achilles Tatius when he eventually associates his heroine with the supernatural and,
indeed, the divine.
Pears presents an absorbing piece of literate
entertainment with an intricate plot, recreating a historical time and place apparently as
accurately as readers would expect from a mystery novel today. Unfortunately, the reader's
illusion of being transported back to the past is broken by a number of verbal
anachronisms -- characters using words or phrases which sound distinctly familiar to our
ears today -- and by mistakes and numerous typographical errors in the book's Latin
quotations. The most embarrassing of the latter appears prominently in the citations to
quotations from Bacon's Novum Organum , which serve as epigraphs to the individual
narrators' stories.
2.
The plot of Heliodorus' novel starts when Persinna, queen of Ethiopia and wife of King
Hydaspes, gives birth to her daughter Chariclea, the story's eventual heroine. Chariclea
is the white child of black parents. This unusual circumstance may have been acceptably
explained to ancient readers by the process of mental imprinting which is given as its
reason in the text (4.8): Persinna had been looking at an image of Andromeda, a white
woman, at the moment of conception. But modern readers might baulk at the physiological
improbability of this (even if they are familiar with the exhaustive and fascinating
history of the "Andromeda Effect" from antiquity to the present as provided by
M.D. Reeve, "Conception," PCPhS 215 (1989) 81-112) and might, as a
result, refuse the suspension of disbelief usually necessary for the enjoyment of
adventure or mystery fiction.
They need, however, not doubt the biological
possibility of black parents producing a white child and doing so even more than once.
This very phenomenon occurred in 1996 and 1998 in England and was duly reported in The
Times of London (10 April 1998; p. 8) under the punning headline "Lightening
strikes twice for black pair."
Carlton and Cynthia Golding (or Goulding; not even
the venerable Times is safe from typographical errors these days) first had a black
son, then a white son "born with blond curly hair," and, eighteen months later,
a white daughter. Despite her earlier experience, the mother seems to have felt the same
way her fictional precursor Persinna must have felt: "I just couldn't believe my eyes
when she was born."
But not to worry. The father is quoted as stating
that "he had had a white great-grandmother" among his Jamaican ancestors. No
less an authority than Richard Dawkins, Oxford University's Professor of the Public
Understanding of Science, has the explanation: "Each individual gets half their genes
from their parents, a quarter from their grandparents, an eighth from the
great-grandparents, and so on," making this "a possible, but extremely unlikely,
occurrence."
Actually, it is not all that unlikely an occurrence,
at least not in England. An independent newspaper recently reported in a syndicated column
another case in which a black couple had not two but three white children (Washington
City Paper , 18 September 1998; p. 19). The parents, Dickson and Cynthia Unoarumhi of
South London, believe they hold the world record in this, and apparently the people from
the Guinness Book of World Records think so, too: they will inaugurate such a
category with the Unoarumhis in 1999. Possible biological reasons advanced in their case
are genetic regression and a parent's carrying a pigment-changing or an albino gene.
If only Heliodorus could have known.......
SAUNDRA SCHWARTZ, COURTROOM SCENES IN ANCIENT GREEK NOVELS .
PH.D. DISSERTATION, COLUMBIA UNIVERSITY, 1998. ADVISOR SUZANNE SAID.
summary by Saundra Schwartz
The trial scene was a favorite topos of the
ancient Greek novels. Chariton, Xenophon of Ephesus, Longus, Achilles Tatius, and
Heliodorus each include at least one scene which features a verbal dispute between two
parties, occasioned by an alleged or actual misdeed, judged by a official, witnessed by an
audience, and entailing punishment or reward. Classical polis , imperial city,
barbarian court, and philosophical utopia provide backdrops for trials.
This study is concerned with the correspondence
of legal realia in the novels to the world of the novels' authors and readers. As my
starting point, I examine how trials function within the narrative framework of individual
novels and consider the influences and parallels from other literary genres. Legal
scenarios and juridical procedures in the novels are then compared with nonliterary
evidence for ancient law, primarily from classical Athens and imperial Rome. Despite their
realistic settings the novels reflect a pastiche of legal details drawn from a (sometimes)
nostalgic vision of the independent polis , as well as from contemporary legal
practices of the Roman empire. The trial scenes in the novels do not shed much light on
the way in which the Greek cities reconciled their laws with the law of their Roman
masters: rather, they reflect an interest in trials as displays of the sufferings and
triumphs of the rich and beautiful. These scenes are artifacts of a world imagined by a
cultured elite which lived during a time when law provided the pretext for dramatic and
savage spectacles.
Chapter 1 surveys modern scholarship on legal realia in the novels and defines the trial
scene. In Chariton, the Syracusan trials of Chaereas and Theron are a study in moral
contrast (chapter 2); the Babylonian trials (chapter 3) fully develop the trial as an
extended drama in the court of a foreign king. Xenophon's trial of Habrocomes by the
prefect of Egypt is contrasted with scenes of punishment in the household (chapter 4).
Consistent with his pastoral vision, Longus features a trial for a pedestrian case of
property damage (chapter 5). The pair of trials in Achilles Tatius is a sophisticated play
on the issue of adultery and murder, two typically novelistic crimes (chapter 6). The
trials of Cnemon and his father in Heliodorus provide ample material for comparison to the
law of Athens (chapter 7). Trials in the courts of the Persian satrap and of the Ethiopian
king form and ideological and moral contrast of ideal rulers (chapter 8). Chapter 9
presents an overview of crime, procedure, magistrates, and punishment. A conclusion
(chapter 10) follows, and an appendix summarizes modern debate on the chronology of the
Greek novels.
AINEIAS TAKTIKOS AND ACHILLES TATIUS
by Wolfgang Hübner
The article Apopudobalia (
) in Der neue Pauly I (1996), 895, written by
M. Meier is a pleasant joke, which provoked another example for the statement that
The History of Petronian scholarship is many times more [...] hilarious, than the
Satyricon itself (K.F.C. Rose, The Petronian Inquisition: an Auto-da-fe, Arion
5, 1966, 275). B.P. Reardon and G. Schmeling take Meiers article picking up
six serious mistakes seriously in a short note in: The Petronian Society
Newsletter, vol. 28 nos. 1 & 2 (May 1998), 14. The title Misdating in
Der Neue Pauly already manifests the main mistake and refers to the novelist
Achilles Tatius. Meier had invented the Gymnastika des Achilleus Taktikos. The
authors criticise that Achilles Tatius (name simply misspelled) has been
misdated to the 4th century B.C. instead of 2nd century A.D. They do not recognize that
the German scholar combined deliberately1 the Greek writer of
strategical matter, Aineias Taktikos (4th century B.C.: see ultimately A. Schürmann, Metzler
Lexikon antiker Autoren, Stuttgart-Weimar 1997, 9f.) and the better known novelist
Achilles Tatius (2nd century A.D.) substituting Achilleus, the
of the Greeks in the homeric Iliad, to
whose namesake was praised by Virgil as the
legendary founder of Rome. By this joke he combined physical power with strategical
tactics translating the realm of war into that of
.
_____________________________
| 1 | Whereas another confusion has not been intended by G. L. Schmeling -- J. H. Stuckey, A Bibliography of Petronius, Leiden 1977 (Mnemosyne suppl. 39), 218 s. v. "Heinse (Heinsius), ed. & tr.": here the famous Dutch Latinist Nicolaas Heinsius (1620-1681) has been confused with the German poet Johann Jakob Wilhelm Heinse (1746-1803). |
PETRONIUS
by Richard I. Pervo
Compton MacKenzie (1883-1972) wrote
more than ninety books, only one of which, Sinister Street, created a bit of a
sensation. This Bildungsroman is remembered, if at all, in the U.S. as a
major influence upon Scott Fitzgeralds This Side of Paradise.
Published in 1913, Sinister Street tells the story of Michael Fane, the
illegitimate son of an upper-class Englishman. It is a fascinating portrait of the
Edwardian age produced before it crashed in utter ruin. Ruins there are, however, for Fane
falls in love with Lily, a beautiful girl of lower-class origins. After the usual
vicissitudes he determines to do the right thing by her, as a kind of alternative to a
religious vocation. Lily eventually flees his rehabilitation and attention. A
quest through the dregs of society leads, in due course, to her discovery as the
partner of another woman, Sylvia, with whom he has a desperate conversation.
Have you ever read
Petronius? she asked suddenly.
Yes, but what an
extraordinary girl you are have you ever read Petronius?
Its the only book in
which anyone in my position with my brains could behold herself. Oh, it is such a
nightmare. And life is a nightmare too. After all, what is life for me? Strange doors in
strange houses. Strange men and strange intimacies. Scenes incredibly grotesque and
incredibly beastly. The secret vileness of human nature flung at me. Man revealing himself
through individual after individual as utterly contemptible. What can I worship? Not my
own body soiled by my traffic in it. Not any religion Ive ever heard of .... it is
beyond my conception ever ever ever to regard a man as higher than a frog, as less
repulsive ... So I worship woman, and in this nightmare city, in this nightmare life, Lily
was always beautiful ... I dont want to worship anything but beauty. I dont
care about purity or uprightness, but I must have beauty. And you came blundering along
and kidnapped my lovely girl ... and all the time I can only see a clumsy frog
[cf. Sat. 77.6].
But what has all this to do
with Petronius? Theres nothing in that romance particularly complimentary to
women, Michael argued.
Its the nightmare
effect of it that I adore, Sylvia exclaimed. Its the sensation of being
hopelessly plunged into a maze of streets from which theres no escape. I was plunged
just like that into London. It is gloriously and sometimes horribly mad, and thats
all I want in my reading now. I want to be given the sensation of other people having been
mad before me ... years ago in a nightmare. Besides, think of the truth, the truth of a
work of art that seems ignorant of goodness. Not one moderately decent person all
through.
(Pp. 800-801 of the Penguin Modern
Classics reprint, Hammondsworth, 1983. This chapter, by the way, is entitled
The Gate of Horn. Emphasis added.)
Sylvias critical perspective
is not without enduring interest. There is a hint of J.P. Sullivan here, as well as the
existentialist nightmare view.
![]()
hits since June 23, 1999
![]()